The Seattle Mariners are facing a potential crisis in their starting rotation, with Bryce Miller's availability for the season's opening in doubt due to an oblique injury. This development opens up an intriguing possibility: could the team consider a comeback for the legendary James Paxton? Paxton, a 37-year-old left-hander, has been making waves in the World Baseball Classic, showcasing his enduring talent and potential. His performance, including a fastball up to 96.5 mph and a mix of pitches, has been nothing short of impressive. The Mariners, who drafted Paxton and witnessed his no-hitter, might be tempted to give him one last shot. The team's current rotation is already bolstered by strong candidates like Emerson Hancock and Cooper Criswell, but Paxton's unique situation and history with the organization could be too tempting to ignore. However, his previous attempt at a reunion with the Mariners ended in tragedy, as he tore his UCL in his first start of the 2021 season. This raises a deeper question: is Paxton's comeback worth the risk, especially considering his age and the short-term nature of the rotation need? The Mariners must decide whether to embrace the romantic notion of Paxton's return or focus on the practical considerations of his potential comeback. In my opinion, the Mariners should consider Paxton's comeback, not only for his pitching prowess but also for the emotional connection he has with the team. His ability to pitch for Canada in the WBC, showcasing his health and performance, adds a layer of intrigue. The team's current situation, with a potential injury to Miller, could be the perfect opportunity for Paxton to make one last impact. The Mariners should weigh the risks and rewards, considering Paxton's history with the team and his desire to pitch in a Mariners uniform. The decision should be guided by the team's best interests and the potential for a memorable ending to Paxton's career. The Mariners' rotation crisis presents an opportunity for a feel-good story, but the decision should be made with a keen eye for the team's long-term success.
